Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Joseph L. Wiess's avatar

I prefer the Philosopher's stone to the Sorcerer's stone because, in myth, the Philosopher's stone was said to be able to turn lead into gold via alchemy. Alchemy required actual years of study as opposed to sorcery, which is an innate talent that can be polished and refined.

Most Americans don't study philosophy, choosing instead to perform active endeavors. It's a rare few that peer into the past and determine the future. Philosophy requires you to constantly think and consider the fact that you might be wrong.

That said, I vastly preferred the books to the movies. Lady Rowling has a way with descriptions that leave the mind boggled. Also, I believe the polyjuice potion did more than change a person's gender. In the books, it changed a person's whole body, mind, and soul, as evidenced by the failed first experiment when Hermione became a cat because she used the wrong hair.

If I were to use Arthurian legends to explain it, Merlin was a philosopher because he had studied the art and warned Arthur of the dangers of using said magic. At the same time, Morgana didn't care about the dangers and went for the brute force use of magic, losing her soul in the act.

Expand full comment

No posts